What does a voice coil do?
The
vast majority of speakers available on the market today are referred to
as electrodynamic. All electrodynamic speakers share a fundamental
aspect of operation: the reaction of a fixed magnetic field against a
changing one. In most electrodynamic speakers, a voice coil, which is a
single coiled length of wire wrapped around a cylinder called a former,
produces the changing magnetic field when alternating current from the
amplifier flows through it.
This current is an electrical representation of the sound that was
produced by the musicians in the recording studio and causes the voice
coil (and therefore the cone or dome attached to it) to react against
the fixed magnetic field produced by the speakers fixed magnet. A
positive pulse should cause the cone to move outward and a negative
pulse should cause the cone to move inward. When the cone moves as a
result of being propelled by the voice coil, it produces the changes in
the air pressure of the listening environment that we perceive as sound.
What is a dual voice coil speaker?
A dual voice coil speaker is simply one in which two separate lengths
of wire are wound together around the same former and terminated
independently. Except for some exotic exceptions, both voice coils have
the same number of turns and length of wire, resulting in identical
electrical characteristics.
Cross-Section View of the Windings of a
Typical Dual Voice Coil Speaker
In
most cases, one coil is wound onto the former first, and the second one
is wound over the first one. Naturally, it is more expensive to wind
and terminate dual voice coils and you will typically pay a small
premium compared to a similar single voice coil speaker. So what do you
get for the extra few bucks? Do dual voice coils offer a performance
advantage? Not really. Do they offer any benefit over a conventional
single voice coil design? Definitely.
What is the advantage of dual voice coils?
The
primary advantage of the dual voice coil speaker is wiring flexibility.
A single dual voice coil driver offers the user three hookup
choices...parallel, series and independent. In a parallel hook-up the
driver's impedance will be half that of each individual coil (a dual 4
ohm speaker would be a 2 ohm speaker in parallel.) A series hook-up
results in twice the impedance of each single coil (a dual 4 ohm
speaker results in 8 ohms if its coils are wired in series.) Finally,
you can wire each voice coil to a separate channel of your amplifier,
which can be useful if your amplifier is not mono-bridgeable or if you
are bridging a four channel amplifier down to two channels to run your
sub.
The independent wiring application is the one that brought about the
need for dual voice coil speakers in home audio. Unlike most good car
amplifiers, home amplifiers and receivers are typically not
mono-bridgeable. For this reason, dual voice coil woofers were
developed so that a subwoofer or center speaker could be driven from
the left and right channels of the average stereo home amp/receiver.
Since sub-bass frequencies are hard to localize, the dual voice coil
subwoofer allowed sub-bass reinforcement within one cabinet and one
speaker. This cabinet could be placed inconspicuously in a corner or
along a wall of the listening room, with the obvious benefits being
space-efficiency and lower cost than two independent bass cabinets or a
larger cabinet with two subs in it. Many popular home subwoofer /
satellite speaker systems still use this basic configuration.
What happens when you run different signals into each voice coil of a dual voice coil speaker?
Essentially,
if there is any difference between the signals driving each coil at any
given point in time at a given frequency, the voice coils will either
fight each other or help each other, depending on the phase
relationship of the two signals at that frequency. This is not the same
thing as bridging an amplifier and can create undesirable
non-linearities and distortion because different input signals at each
voice coil create shifts in the speakers electrical parameters.
For this reason, it is advisable to mono-bridge the amplifier whenever
possible and connect the voice coils of the dual voice coil speaker
together in parallel or series. If a dual voice coil subwoofer must be
wired to two independent channels, the inputs to both channels should
ideally be the same (summed mono) and every effort should be made to
match the gains of both channels as closely as possible. |
Whats the point of a dual voice coil speaker if I have a mono-bridgeable amp?
Because almost every modern car audio amplifier is either
mono-bridgeable or a monoblock (one channel), it is just as easy to run
a single voice coil sub in mono as it is to run a dual voice coil sub
in mono. Where a dual voice coil subwoofer has an advantage is in
giving the user greater wiring flexibility while avoiding
speaker-to-speaker series connections.
Let's compare a few drivers and look at the flexibility differences. We
know that an 8 ohm speaker and a dual 4 ohm speaker are very similar.
To design the dual 4 ohm speaker, the 8 ohm speaker's voice coil is
basically split into two coils, each having half of the original
impedance. The advantage of the dual 4 ohm speaker is that it can be
configured as an 8 ohm driver (with the two coils in series) or as a 2
ohm driver (with the two coils in parallel), while the 8 ohm speaker is
capable of only one impedance. If your amplifier is designed to run at
higher impedances, either driver would work well. If your amplifier is
designed to produce optimum performance at lower impedances, using the
dual 4 ohm driver and connecting the voice coils in parallel to yield a
2 ohm impedance makes the most sense.
The
benefits of the dual voice coil design are even more apparent with
multiple subwoofer installations. If we were to use two of either of
the drivers mentioned above, what would the final impedance
possibilities be? With two of the dual 4 ohm drivers we can wire the
voice coils of each driver in series and the drivers in parallel and
get a 4 ohm final impedance. We can also wire the voice coils of each
driver in parallel and the drivers in parallel and get a 1 ohm final
impedance.With two of the single 8 ohm drivers, only a 4 ohm final
impedance can be the result of recommended wiring. Why? Because all
driver-to-driver wiring should be done in parallel and two 8 ohm
drivers wired in parallel will yield a 4 ohm final impedance.
It is far
less desirable to make subwoofer to subwoofer connections in series.
Because of slight and unavoidable differences between speakers and
because of the high likelihood of uneven loading between different
speakers in a car, there will be slight differences in the mechanical
behavior of the two speakers in series. These differences in movement
result in induced voltage (called back EMF) being created by the
speakers across the series connection. This effect causes a problem
when two speakers which behave differently are connected in series
because the speakers can modulate each other (cause each other to
move), resulting in distortion. The problem becomes more serious as
more speakers are connected in series.
A good experiment to show the effect of back EMF is the following:
connect four speakers in series and short the positive and negative
input leads of the series circuit. Push down on one cone with your
hand; you will notice that the three other speakers will move in the
opposite direction of the one you are pushing. Now, reconnect the
speakers in parallel, short the inputs and push down on one cone. The
speakers will not modulate each other because each one is shorted
directly.
Back EMF modulation is not a concern when the voice coils of a dual
voice coil speaker are wired in series to each other because the coils
are physically coupled on one moving mass. Therefore, they cannot
possibly modulate each other because they cannot move independently.
Does It Matter How The Voice Coils Are Wired To Each Other?
A
dual voice coil speaker will behave exactly the same way whether it is
wired with its coils in series or parallel. The only thing that changes
is the impedance that the amplifier sees. This means that enclosure
calculations are constant for dual voice coil woofers no matter how the
coils are connected to each other, as long as both are connected.
A common misconception with regard to dual voice coil speakers is the
assumption that nothing changes if you power only one of the voice
coils. With only one coil hooked up, a dual voice coil speaker will
suffer a loss in reference efficiency of about 3dB (only half the coil
windings are being energized) as well as a significant shift in its
Thiele/Small parameters. This renders any enclosure calculations
inaccurate unless you remeasure the speakers parameters with only one
coil hooked up. Failure to account for the different parameters of a
dual voice coil speaker with only one coil powered can result in very
poor performance.
How are dual voice coil speakers rated for power handling?
A dual voice coil speaker's power handling is typically specified by
manufacturers for the whole speaker. This means that a 250 Watt dual
voice coil driver is designed to handle a total of 250 Watts whether
the coils are wired independently, in series or in parallel.
|